Nov. 11, 2022
Previous Next

LLNL physicist probes causes of life-shortening 'dwell fatigue' in titanium

Jeremy Thomas, thomas244 [at], (925) 422-5539

"Dwell fatigue" is a phenomenon that can occur in titanium alloys when held under stress, such as a jet engine's fan disc during takeoff. This peculiar failure mode can initiate microscopic cracks that drastically reduce a component's lifetime.  

The most widely used titanium alloy, Ti-6Al-4V, was not believed to exhibit dwell fatigue before the 2017 Air France Flight 066 incident, in which an Airbus en route from Paris to Los Angeles suffered fan disc failure over Greenland that forced an emergency landing. The analysis of that incident and several more recent concerns prompted the Federal Aviation Administration and European Union Aviation Safety Agency to coordinate work across the aerospace industry to determine the root causes of dwell fatigue.

According to experts, metals deform predominantly via dislocation slip — the movement of line defects in the underlying crystal lattice. Researchers hold that dwell fatigue can initiate when slip is restricted to narrow bands instead of occurring more homogenously in three dimensions. The presence of nanometer-scale intermetallic Ti3Al precipitates promotes band formation, particularly when processing conditions allow for their long-range ordering.

Things get dicey when this banding behavior occurs across a contiguous group of 'soft'-oriented grains, termed a “macrozone,” researchers explained. The resultant deformation concentration, where the band meets a “hard”-oriented grain outside the macrozone, leads to a stress concentration, initiating the cracking process. Further complicating things, dislocation slip occurs intermittently in bursts or "avalanches," similar to how small fault slippage events can initiate more significant earthquakes. The magnitude and frequency of these slip avalanches strongly influence the initiation of dwell fatigue.

In a recent study by a multi-national team, including current and former Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory (LLNL) scientists, researchers used synchrotron X-rays to track discrete slip avalanche events in titanium held under load at room temperature. A team from Imperial College London provided specimens of specially prepared Ti–7Al, an alloy representing a surrogate for the primary phase in Ti-6Al-4V. The populations of two-point defect types were modulated across the specimens: interstitial oxygen content and the amount of ordered Ti3Al precipitates.

The study, published in Nature Communications, shows that where the Ti3Al exhibits ordering, slip avalanches are more severe in associated stress magnitude. In contrast, increasing the amount of interstitial oxygen appears to reduce the severity, promoting more frequent smaller avalanches.

"This work offers a novel, mesoscale view of the intermittent deformation events (little "bursts" of plastic slip) underpinning dwell fatigue, specifically how the frequency and magnitude of those events depend on oxygen content and alloying," said co-author and LLNL physicist Joel Bernier. "These data can help guide processing to avoid microstructures that have a deleterious effect on resistance to dwell fatigue."

Bernier helped execute high-energy X-ray diffraction microscopy measurements at the Cornell High Energy Synchrotron Source (CHESS) and performed the data reduction using the LLNL-developed HEXRD software library. The team quantified the frequency and magnitude of stress bursts resulting from slip avalanches and found that both types of point defects had pronounced effects on slip occurring on the crystal lattice's basal planes.

Researchers discovered that this deformation mechanism becomes easier to activate after the initial yielding, a softening known to be a precursor to damage accumulation and failure in instances of dwell fatigue. Among the key findings: higher concentration of oxygen interstitials reduced the average magnitude of the basal slip avalanches by promoting more frequent lower-magnitude events.

In contrast, expanding the size of ordered Ti2Al precipitates, by aging the material at an elevated temperature, increased both the frequency and the magnitude of slip avalanches, increasing the probability of crack initiation. According to the team, these findings can help optimize the processing of titanium alloys for resistance to dwell fatigue.

Part of the funding came from a Laboratory Directed Research and Development project headed by Bernier. Co-authors included Felicity Worsnop, Yilun Xu, Thomas McAuliffe, and David Dye of Imperial College London; Rachel Lim and Darren Pagan of Pennsylvania State University; and David Rugg, formerly of Rolls Royce.